Illinois Supreme Court Justice Mary Jane Theis announces retirement

Court appoints Chicago appellate court justice as her replacement

By BEN SZALINSKI
Capitol News Illinois
bszalinski@capitolnewsillinois.com

Article Summary

  • Illinois Supreme Court Justice Mary Jane Theis announced she will retire from the court at the end of January following 15 years as a justice.

  • Theis, a Democrat, served three years as chief justice, with her term as the head of the court ending in October 2025.

  • Theis authored the majority opinion in the 2023 case that upheld the SAFE-T Act and allowed Illinois to eliminate cash bail. 

  • Cook County Appellate Court Justice Sanjay Tailor was appointed to replace Theis on the court. 

This summary was written by the reporters and editors who worked on this story. 

SPRINGFIELD — Illinois Supreme Court Justice Mary Jane Theis announced she will retire from the state’s high court later this month. 

Theis, a Democrat from Chicago who represents the Cook County district on the court, said in a statement Monday she will vacate the bench Jan. 29 after first being appointed to the court in 2010. 

“I am deeply grateful to have had the opportunity to serve,” Theis said in a statement. “It has been my foremost goal to further the Court’s mission of providing access to equal justice, ensuring judicial integrity and upholding the rule of law.”

Theis was elected to a full term in 2012 and appointed chief justice in 2022. Her term as head of the court ended last October when Chief Justice P. Scott Neville was appointed the new leader of the court.

Read more: P. Scott Neville Jr. chosen as next chief justice on Illinois Supreme Court

Theis played a role in several impactful decisions, including the Democratic-majority court’s ruling allowing Illinois to abolish cash bail in 2023.

Theis authored the majority opinion in favor of the controversial and pioneering law, which many opponents said violates the constitutional requirement that people charged with a crime receive bail. Theis wrote the state constitution does not require bail to be monetary and is not the only mechanism that can be used to ensure a person returns to court for trial. She noted the General Assembly amended the state’s bail laws many times over the years. 

Read more: Cash bail will end in Illinois as justices rule SAFE-T Act provisions constitutional

“If the legislature could reconsider bail over the course of so many years, it could do so again in 2021 without offending separation of powers principles,” Theis wrote of the SAFE-T Act, which lawmakers passed in early 2021. 

She argued the law creates a “presumption” in favor of pretrial release, meaning “the state bears the burden of establishing a defendant’s eligibility for pretrial detention.”

During Theis’ tenure as chief justice, the Supreme Court guided the implementation of the new cashless bail pretrial procedure in Illinois. The Supreme Court oversees the administration of the entire Illinois court system. 

New justice to join the court

First District Appellate Court Justice Sanjay Tailor was appointed by the court to fill Theis’ vacancy on the seven-justice court beginning at the end of the month. Tailor will serve until at least December 2028, when Cook County voters will decide who will be given a full 10-year term on the bench. 

Tailor has been a Cook County judge since 2003 and became an appellate court judge in 2022, according to a news release from the Supreme Court. 

He previously worked as an assistant state’s attorney in Cook County and as a private attorney. Tailor will be the first Asian American on the Illinois Supreme Court. 

Capitol News Illinois is a nonprofit, nonpartisan news service that distributes state government coverage to hundreds of news outlets statewide. It is funded primarily by the Illinois Press Foundation and the Robert R. McCormick Foundation.  

Supreme Court Justice Mary Jane Theis listens to remarks from the bench at the Illinois Supreme Court in Springfield. (Capitol News Illinois file photo)

Mt. Carmel Man Pleads Not Guilty To Domestic Violence Charges

A Mt. Carmel man facing multiple domestic violence charges will remain behind bars as his case moves toward trial.

Thirty-four-year-old Jeremy Birkla was in court Thursday, where he waived his preliminary hearing and entered a plea of not guilty to all charges. A motion for pre-trial release was denied, with the court finding that Birkla’s continued detention is necessary to avoid a real and present threat to the safety of individuals or the community, based on the specific, articulable facts of the case.

Birkla remains lodged in the Wabash County Jail.

According to court records, Birkla is charged with aggravated domestic battery, a Class 2 felony, after he allegedly choked his girlfriend during an incident on November 23rd. He also faces charges of unlawful restraint for allegedly preventing the woman from leaving the residence, domestic battery for reportedly striking her in the face, and interference with the reporting of domestic violence after allegedly taking her phone to keep her from calling police or medical personnel.

Prosecutors have also filed a separate domestic battery charge related to an incident on November 21st, along with criminal damage to property for allegedly breaking the victim’s vehicle window on November 10th.

Pre-trial conferences are scheduled for January 22nd and February 19th, with a jury trial set for March 2nd.

Court records also show Birkla previously pled guilty to involuntary manslaughter in the 2012 death of Billy Gunzel and was sentenced to probation and periodic imprisonment.

Former Deputy Enters Not Guilty Plea After Probable Cause Found

The long-delayed preliminary hearing for former Wabash County Sheriff’s Deputy Chase Cheadle was finally held Thursday, where a judge found probable cause in the case. Cheadle entered a plea of not guilty to the remaining charges. A pretrial hearing has been scheduled for February 19th.

Cheadle’s preliminary hearing had been postponed multiple times, with delays dating back to November of 2024.

The former sheriff’s department canine handler was originally charged with eight counts, including four counts of official misconduct, one count of theft, one count of cruelty to animals, and two counts of animal owner duties violations. Five of those charges were felonies.

However, in June, Special Prosecutor Brian Towne requested dismissal of two felony counts, the theft charge and one count of official misconduct , which were granted by the court.

According to investigators, the 30-year-old Cheadle found his K-9 partner, Kiki, unresponsive in July of 2024. He was later arrested following the investigation and resigned from the Wabash County Sheriff’s Department one month later.

Following Profane Posts, Dean Ditches Facebook

Wabash County Commissioner Rob Dean says he has stepped away from Facebook following controversy over profane posts made after the county board approved a large-scale solar farm last month.

During last week’s county board meeting, Dean told fellow commissioners and the public that he is no longer on the social media platform, saying the decision has reduced stress. Dean said, “The good news is I’m not on Facebook anymore. So I haven’t had any stress or anything. So it’s been good. That was by my choosing, and it took me a long time to smarten up and do that.”

Dean’s comments follow backlash after he used profanity in Facebook posts aimed at residents who questioned the county’s approval of a solar project covering more than 3,000 acres near the former Friendsville Mine.

Tensions escalated during a recent county board meeting when Dean criticized Mount Carmel Mayor Joe Judge for liking a Facebook post opposing the solar farm. Judge later said the “like” was simply to acknowledge being tagged, not an endorsement of the post.

Dean later returned to Facebook, again using profane language to challenge opponents of the project, telling them to run for office. Those posts have since been deleted.

Five candidates are currently seeking the county commissioner seat held by Scott West, who is not seeking re-election in 2026. Dean’s seat on the county board will not be up for election until 2028.

Commissioners Hear Update On Water Quality

“MT. CARMEL WATER PLANT IS NOW PRODUCINJG BETTER QUALITY WATER THAN IT EVER HAS” SAID WATER PLANT SUPERINTENDENT KEITH REED, PROVIDING AN UPDATE ON A RECENT TAG BY THE STATE, FOR T.O.C. RATES. THE CITY PROVIDED A MASS-MAILING INFORMING CUSTOMERS OF THE NOTICE. AT MONDAY’S CITY COUNCIL MEETING, REED EMPHASIZED THE WATER HAS ALWAYS BEEN SAFE TO DRINK, ALL DURING 2025…INCLUDING DURING THE JULY THRU SEPTEMBER VIOLATION PERIOD. REED SAID, ALTHOUGH THE T.O.C. REMOVAL RATE WAS SLIGHTLY HIGHER IN 2025…THE AMOUNT OF T. O.C. IN THE WATER WAS LESS IN 2025. NEW SAMPLES WERE SENT IN MONDAY.

Evansville Man Found Guilty On 5 Of 7 Counts

The jury trial of 33-year-old Devin Brittain of Evansville concluded last night in Wabash County Circuit Court with mixed verdicts returned after several hours of deliberation.

Brittain appeared in court in street clothes and without restraints, accompanied by his attorney, Anthony Cervantez. All jurors and an alternate were present as the state completed its case-in-chief and rested. The defense moved for a directed verdict, but the court ruled that, when viewed in the light most favorable to the state, a reasonable jury could find Brittain guilty beyond a reasonable doubt on all counts.

Following closing arguments and jury instructions, the jury began deliberations at 3:45 Wednesday afternoon. Jurors submitted a question to the court shortly before 6 p.m., which was answered by the judge after consultation with counsel. Deliberations continued into the evening.

At 7:01 p.m., the jury returned verdicts finding Brittain guilty on Counts One through Three which are aggravated domestic battery, aggravated battery on a peace officer, aggravated battery causing great bodily harm, , not guilty on Counts Four and Five aggravated battery on a nurse and criminal damage to property, and guilty on Counts Six and Seven which were two charges of criminal damage to property over $500.

A pre-sentence investigation was ordered, and a sentencing hearing has been scheduled for February 9th at 1 p.m. Brittain was ordered detained until sentencing under Illinois law.

 

Serious bodily injury accident on State Road 65 north of Princeton

On January 5, 2026, at 5:13 p.m. Gibson County Central Dispatch received a 911 report of a head on crash on State Road 65 approximately one half a mile south of County Road 400 North in the rural Patoka area.  Emergency service personnel were dispatched to the scene where they found a Silver 2002 Lexus RX3 was Southbound on State Road 65 and reportedly crossed the center of the roadway and struck a Tan 2017 Chrysler Pacifica that was Northbound. 
 
Patoka Township Fire and Union Fire worked together to extricate injured passengers from their vehicles and the Gibson County Ambulance Service transported injured parties to area hospitals for further treatment.  At the time of this report one person was critically injured in this accident and at least two suffered non-life-threatening injuries.
 
This accident was investigated by the Gibson County Sheriff’s Office and Gibson County Sheriff’s Office D.A.R.T (Drone Ariel Response Team.)  The Princeton Police also assisted in securing this accident scene. 
 
This is an active and open serious bodily injury accident. 
 

Third time isn't a charm for homeless dine and dash thief.

On January 3, 2025, at approximately 1: 37 p.m. Gibson County Central Dispatch received a report from Denny’s Restaurant located at 1989 South State Road 57 outside of Oakland City that a man had ordered food and left the establishment without paying the $31.67 balance.  Deputy Jim Tucker arrived on scene and showed a picture of the suspect from the Lupe’s and Applebee’s dine and dash incidents from the day before to the employees and they positively identified the suspect as the same person.  Further they gave a description of the male as wearing a black sock hat, gray hoodie, and dark pants and began a search of the area.  After a brief search, 44-year-old Derek Scott Jones was located and taken into custody behind a dumpster at ProRehab an establishment which is across the street.
 
After a brief investigation Mr. Jones was taken into custody and charged with two counts of Theft.  Mr. Jones has an extensive criminal history and currently has 9 non-extraditable warrants out of Illinois. 
 
Deputy Tucker was assisted in his investigation by Deputy Michael Owens and Oakland City Police Chief Tim Gaines.  The Princeton Police Department also aided in the investigation and charges on Mr. Jones.    
 
All criminal defendants are to be presumed innocent until and unless proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt in a court of law.

New laws: Illinois education measures focus on immigrant rights, AI in the classroom

Measures that provide legal protections for students, guidelines for schools take effect Jan. 1

By PETER HANCOCK
Capitol News Illinois
phancock@capitolnewsillinois.com

Story Summary

  • Illinois lawmakers responded to President Trump’s crackdown on immigrant communities with new legal protections for students and guidelines for schools that will take effect Jan. 1.

  • Community colleges will be barred from using AI bots to teach classes in lieu of human faculty.

  • The Illinois State Board of Education will begin drafting guidelines on the use of AI in K-12 settings.

This summary was written by the reporters and editors who worked on this story.

SPRINGFIELD — Immigrant rights and artificial intelligence were two of the hot-button issues that influenced public education in 2025. They are also the subject of new education-related laws that will take effect at the start of the new year.

The rights of noncitizen students, including those who are not lawfully present in the U.S., rose to the top of the education agenda as soon as President Donald Trump was sworn in to his second term in January. 

The day Trump was inaugurated, the Department of Homeland Security rescinded a Biden administration policy that had limited immigration enforcement actions in or near “sensitive locations” such as schools, playgrounds, child care centers and school bus stops.

Two days later, Illinois Superintendent of Education Tony Sanders issued what he called “non-regulatory guidance” to local school officials, urging them to adopt policies spelling out how and when their staff should cooperate with federal immigration officials carrying out enforcement actions or seeking information from school officials.

At the Statehouse, the Democratic-controlled General Assembly also took action, passing bills intended to extend more legal protections to noncitizens living in Illinois. 

School program participation

Among those was House Bill 3247, which passed the General Assembly in the final days of the spring session in May and was signed into law Aug. 15. It prohibits schools from excluding or discouraging students from attending school or taking part in school programs based on their immigration status or that of their parents or guardians.

“In the face of federal threats to our schools and students, our communities came together and organized to demand that our state leaders stand up for education for all Illinois children,” Lawrence Benito, executive director of the Illinois Coalition for Immigrant and Refugee Rights, said in a statement after the bill’s final approval.

“While the right to safe and free public education remains under attack from Trump and leaders in other states, Illinois has the opportunity to continue to uphold our values.”

The law specifically prohibits schools from requesting or collecting information from a student, their parents or guardians about their citizenship or immigration status unless the information is required by state or federal law. 

It also prohibits schools from disclosing information about their immigration or citizenship status to any other person or entity, including immigration and law enforcement agencies, unless required to do so under federal law.

In addition, starting July 1, schools that violate those prohibitions can be sued in civil court for actual damages.

Scholarships and immigration status

Another new law expands the types of publicly funded scholarships students can qualify for regardless of their citizenship or immigration status.

Illinois law already extends eligibility for state-funded student financial aid such as the Monetary Award Program, or MAP grants, to any student who meets Illinois residency requirements. House Bill 460, which was signed into law in August, expands that to include programs administered by local units of government.

Artificial Intelligence in college

The rapid deployment in recent years of new technologies like ChatGPT, Copilot and Gemeni has raised a host of new questions for educators. Should students be allowed to use them in lieu of doing their own reading and writing? And should schools themselves be allowed to use them in lieu of human instructors to lead classes?

Illinois lawmakers addressed some of those questions.

House Bill 1859 requires community colleges to ensure that faculty members who teach courses must be actual people who meet the qualifications to hold their positions. It also provides that colleges may not, in lieu of a faculty member, use AI programs “as the sole source of instruction.” It does, however, allow faculty members to use AI as a teaching tool in their classrooms.

“Artificial intelligence is a powerful tool that can enhance both students’ and teachers’ capability to learn and teach, but it cannot replace an instructor,” Rep. Abdelnasser Rashid, D-Bridgeview, the bill’s lead House sponsor, said in a statement. “This legislation clarifies that college courses must be taught by real people, not AI.”

AI at elementary and secondary schools

Lawmakers were less specific about how AI should be handled at the elementary and secondary education levels. Instead, they directed the Illinois State Board of Education to develop broad guidelines.

Senate Bill 1920 directs ISBE to develop statewide guidance for districts and educators on the use of AI in K-12 settings. That includes a basic explanation of what AI is and how it works as well as descriptions of how it can be used in the classroom “to inform teaching and learning practices while preserving the human relationships essential to effective teaching and learning.”

The law also directs ISBE to include guidance on the impact AI systems and applications could have on student data privacy, on best practices for teaching students about responsible and ethical uses of AI, and the dangers of “unintentional and disparate biases against special populations inherent within artificial intelligence products.”

The law directs ISBE to publish those guidelines by July 1.

Other education laws

Also beginning Jan. 1, students in seventh and eighth grade will be able to get an early jump on earning high school credits. 

House Bill 3039 authorizes districts to award credits to seventh and eighth graders who enroll in high school classes as long as they pass both the course and the end-of-course examination demonstrating they have achieved high school-level proficiency.

House Bill 1366 requires districts to notify the parents or guardians of students with special needs that they have a right to bring a third-party advocate with them to meetings about their student’s Individual Education Plan, or IEP meetings.


Capitol News Illinois is a nonprofit, nonpartisan news service that distributes state government coverage to hundreds of news outlets statewide. It is funded primarily by the Illinois Press Foundation and the Robert R. McCormick Foundation. 


Immigrant rights advocates demonstrate outside the Illinois Statehouse in Springfield in May, urging passage of legislation to guarantee all children the right to a free public education regardless of their immigration or citizenship status. (Capitol News Illinois photo by Peter Hancock)

Illinois maternal mortality report finds rise in pregnancy-related deaths

Black women were more than twice as likely as white women to die from a pregnancy-related condition 

By MAGGIE DOUGHERTY
Capitol News Illinois
mdougherty@capitolnewsillinois.com 

Article Summary 

  • Illinois’ fourth report on maternal mortality trends identified 94 pregnancy-related deaths in 2021 and 2022, an increase from past reports.

  • The report found that 91% of all pregnancy-related deaths were potentially preventable, including all those resulting from mental health conditions or substance use disorders.

  • Black Illinoisians had the highest rates of maternal mortality, with discrimination identified as a contributing factor in nearly three-quarters of deaths. 

  • Pregnant people on Medicaid or with a high school or lower level of education died more frequently from pregnancy-related conditions than their counterparts on private insurance or with post-secondary education.

This summary was written by the reporters and editors who worked on this story. 

CHICAGO — Preventable pregnancy-related deaths rose and stark racial disparities remained in the Illinois Department of Public Health’s most recent maternal mortality report.

The report studied 219 deaths that occurred in Illinois in 2021 and 2022 during or within one year of pregnancy. The two committees that reviewed the deaths determined 94 to be related to pregnancy. This is an increase from past data, which have been published in two-to-three-year increments since 2015. 

ALL DEATHS BY YEAR CHART

https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/27021118/

“Each maternal death represents far more than a statistic: it is a profound and often preventable loss that leaves lasting emotional, social, and economic scars on families, communities, and society,” the report stated. “Beyond the immediate tragedy, each loss signals a broader failure to provide equitable, comprehensive, and culturally competent maternal care.”

Of the pregnancy-related deaths that occurred in 2021 and 2022, the committees found 91% could have been prevented. 

Common causes

As in past years, substance use disorder remained the most common cause of pregnancy-related death, accounting for nearly a third of the deaths in the recent data. Other leading causes included blood clots and COVID-19, which rose in prevalence as the cause of death in 12% and 11% of deaths, respectively. Deaths due to hemorrhage, or postpartum bleeding, doubled to 10% from 5% in the previous period.

Black Illinoisians had the highest rate of maternal mortality at 78 deaths per 100,000 live births. The report found discrimination was present in 74% of the deaths related to Black pregnancies, making it the most common contributing factor in Black pregnancy-related deaths.

In August, Gov. JB Pritzker signed House Bill 2517, requiring obstetric care providers to take anti-bias training. The course was designed to educate maternal health care providers on historic racial discrepancies to reduce implicit biases and improve health outcomes.

MATERNAL MORTALITY BY CAUSE CATEGORY CHART

https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26877196/

Black mothers were more than twice as likely as white mothers to die from any pregnancy-related cause, including substance use disorder or mental health conditions, but more than three times as likely to die from purely medical pregnancy-related conditions.

Obesity was the second most common contributing factor for Black maternal deaths, followed by mental health conditions and substance use disorder. 

Mental health conditions can include postpartum depression, in which individuals may develop feelings of suicidal ideation or wanting to self-harm after pregnancy. Substance use disorder results in a pattern of uncontrolled use of drugs, medication or inhalants that poorly affects an individual’s ability to function, including failure to meet obligations at school, work or home.

Mental health conditions were the most common contributing factor for white and Hispanic pregnancy-related deaths. Discrimination was also a factor in nearly a third of deaths for Hispanic maternal deaths, while substance use disorder was only present in 9% of deaths for that population. 

Substance use disorder was more prevalent in white pregnancy-related deaths than those of other racial groups, present in one-in-three deaths.

The committees found that all deaths due to mental health conditions and substance use disorder were potentially preventable, with approximately 20% of those classified as having a “good chance” of prevention had there been “reasonable changes to any provider, facility, patient, community, or system.”

MATERNAL MORTALITY BY YEAR STORY

https://public.flourish.studio/story/3512701/

Those with a high school education or less were more than twice as likely to die from a pregnancy-related cause than those with a post-secondary education. Medicaid recipients died from pregnancy-related conditions almost four times as frequently as those with private insurance.

Geography, timing

Rates of pregnancy-related mortality were highest in urban counties outside of the Chicago area and in the city of Chicago, with maternal mortality rates in Chicago increasing over the last three report periods.

Counties surrounding Cook County, namely DuPage, Kane, Lake, McHenry and Will, had the lowest levels of pregnancy-related mortality. 

MATERNAL MORTALITY BY GEOGRAPHY CHART

https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26878668/

The maternal mortality rate in rural counties decreased marginally since the past data period. But the report noted that pregnant people in rural locations still face barriers — including lack of providers and long travel distances — to accessing specialized care for mental health services, substance use disorder and other chronic conditions.

Fewer than a third of pregnancy-related deaths reviewed in the report happened during pregnancy, with 43% occurring within the first month after pregnancy and another third of deaths occurring two or more months after pregnancy. Deaths due to substance use disorder and mental health conditions were more likely to occur after birth.

Recommendations

The report presents four key recommendations outlined in the Illinois Blueprint for Birth Equity, a multi-agency and stakeholder project aimed at improving maternal health care and birth outcomes in the state. 

The blueprint, released in September 2025 with the input of advocates, experts and health care providers, is part of a larger birth equity initiative spearheaded by Black midwives and doulas in collaboration with Lt. Gov. Juliana Stratton.

Read more: Pritzker signs birth equity initiative into law, celebrates Medicaid expansion | General Assembly passes bill to mandate anti-bias training for obstetric care providers

Those recommendations centered around expanding access to quality and specialized care. It called on health insurance plans, including Medicaid, to incentivize maternal health providers to practice in rural areas and small hospitals. 

It also recommended that hospitals employ a social worker or case manager to help with resource coordination and postpartum case management, as well as engaging in more coordination with community-based midwives and doulas.

Building on the blueprint’s recommendations, the Illinois Department of Healthcare and Family Services announced new coverage for pregnant and parenting Medicaid customers. That change means that Medicaid now covers home visiting services, including health education, blood pressure monitoring, behavioral health screenings, domestic violence education and screenings, stress management and service referrals. 

The program, which took effect on Nov. 21, 2025, was intended to bridge gaps in access to timely, quality care, according to DHFS. Home visits can replace or supplement in-clinic care for families with limited access to transportation, busy work schedules or other barriers to attending appointments.

In a letter introducing the blueprint, Stratton outlined the Pritzker administration’s commitment to improving maternal health and birth equity.

“Every woman deserves to bring life into this world safely and with dignity, and every family deserves to bring their child home with the resources they need to grow,” Stratton wrote. 

“Whether you’re in the heart of Chicago’s loop or on a farm in Tuscola, Ill., no family should welcome a new soul with grief for the one who carried it.”

Capitol News Illinois is a nonprofit, nonpartisan news service that distributes state government coverage to hundreds of news outlets statewide. It is funded primarily by the Illinois Press Foundation and the Robert R. McCormick Foundation.

Doctor listens to a pregnant woman’s abdomen using a stethoscope. (Photo Credit: Krakenimages.com, adobe stock)